Soul and
Spirit: A Comparison
by Kenneth G. Hamilton, MD ~ Spring 98 Edition
"Soul and spirit are often used
interchangeably. It has not always been so. In Western
society, people once spoke of four elements of human
beings: body, mind, soul, and spirit. Between
two and three hundred years ago, during the Burning
Times and the so-called Age of Enlightenment,
we suppressed women as healers, mystics and spiritual
leaders. Church leaders associated soul with these feminine
aspects of ourselves, and suppressed all references
to the soul, making it the same as spirit. Thus we came
to see ourselves as only body, mind and spirit.
Today, however, soul has become the subject of many
popular writings, and it is returning to our consciousness
of self. We can no longer deny the existence of soul
any more than we can suppress or deny the existence
of spirit. As we are in the process today of remembering
that sad part of our history, soul and spirit are not
synonymous, and yet they certainly do have similarities.
By examining our old traditions of thought and our popular
idioms we can see how soul and spirit differ and what
they also have in common.
In The Divine Comedy Dante Alighieri tells us that
there is but one commandment, Be! and there
is but one response, I am! The commandment
is the source of life, the spirit that continues to
transform all being. The response is the essence of
life, the soul that is in relationship to all of the
responses to Be! The source, spirit, is
ethereal, and, like the breath (Latin, spiritus) it
can not be grasped. The essence, soul, is tangible,
and, ones body (Latin, anima) feels its presence.
The spirit is fundamental and transcendent (Kabbala,
Maqom), universal and collective. The soul is manifest
and immanent (Kabbala, Shekhina), personal and individual.
Spirit is the masculine (yang) principle of life, whereas
soul is the feminine (yin) principle. Spirit sets the
concept of existence, and soul is the content and context
of existence. The first three chakras, the chakras of
form (body), contain the essence of life, the soul,
the experience of being. The next four chakras, the
chakras of concept (mind), connect the body or form
to the spirit, the foundation of being.
Soul and spirit have properties in common, especially
those that make them both eternal and infinite
time and space do not define them. The great truths
of the Universe can not be defined, they can only be
described. The infinite, eternal aspect of spirit is
quite easy to grasp, but when one thinks of soul it
appears more finite. However, as Heraclitus would have
us know, You would not find out the boundaries
of the soul, even by traveling along every path: so
deep a measure does it have. Indeed, we can not
take the measure of either soul or spirit. Neither can
we understand them; for to understand is to stand under
as Atlas stands under the world and takes the measure
of its size and weight. Thus we take the measure of
whatever it is we stand under or understand. However,
by traveling along the paths of soul and spirit, we
can experience them. In the experience of them we encounter
that which flows from deep within both of them
love. For our purposes here, we describe love as caritas
or agape rather than as eros, sexual love or passion.
This love is without condition and it is the quality
of all of the relationships of soul and spirit.
For us humans, the younger we are the more difficult
it is to sense these qualities, because they are subjected
to the loud, attention-getting, soul-shadowing demands
of the ego. Ego takes the credit for making individuals
of each of us. Soul and spirit are then shy of the ego,
and, on the other hand, the ego fears these infinite,
eternal qualities that speak to the awesome strength
and integrity that comes with their limitless qualities.
Soul and spirit can wait for the ranting and raving
of the ego to fade into time, biding that finite time
with their timelessness until it is right for the individual
to recognize that there is this dimensionless aspect
of her or his life. These qualities of soul and spirit
are the paradigm of wholeness and health. They are also
the source of all of the lasting examples of our creativity.
They live in the Parthenon, in Beethovens Ninth
Symphony, in the splendor of the Taj Mahal, and in the
majestic wonder of Machu Picchu.
For those who enjoy discussion and argument about the
nature of soul and spirit, let this introduction become
the basis for a wide variety of dialogs about the nature
of human psychospiritual experience. Because in some
ways they are opposites, soul and spirit are not the
Source of the Universe, but they are manifestations
of that Source. Insofar as they are similar, they are
close to the Source. As we come to learn more about
them, their similarities take us nearer to that Source
because they resolve some of our most challenging paradoxes.
As our awareness of both grows it leads us to the appreciation
of our potential to take part in the greatest transformation
that our species has ever undertaken
indeed, soul
and spirit are the focal dynamic, the engine, of this
transformation.
SOUL
Essence of Life
I am! (Being)
Manifest
Immanent, Shekhina
Tangible
Psyche
Anima
Personal
Individual
Feminine Principle of creation
Yin
Form belongs to soul
Chakras 1-3
Body the container
Context, Content
Relational |
SPIRIT
Source of Life
Be!
Fundamental
Transcendent, Maqom
Ethereal
Pneuma
Spiritus
Universal
Collective
Masculine Principle of creation
Yang
Mind belongs to spirit
Chakras 4-7
Mind the connector
Concept
Transformative |
|
Qualities of Both
|
|
Eternal
Infinite
Indefinable
Describable
|
Experiential
Loving
Truthful
Creative
|
The Art and Soul of Healing: top
An Experience in Relationship-Centered Care
Helping medical and mental health care providers bring
relationship-centered care to their practises is the
focus of a weekend workshop that HOPE and the University
of New England College of Osteopathic Medicine are hosting
in June. This 2 1/2 day workshop will take place June
12 to 14 at Hebron Academy in Hebron, Maine. The cost
for the workshop is $150 to $200 (sliding scale). Room
and Board will be $75 for a double room or $100 for
a single room for the entire weekend.
12.5 Category 2B CME credits from the American Osteopathic
Association and contact hour certificates will be earned.
Joining HOPEs founder, Ken Hamilton MD, as
facilitators for this workshop will be Jane Hindle Bamberg,
M.S.Ed, Barbara Sinclair, Ph.D., Bruce St. Thomas, Ed.D.,
and Susan Thompson, M.Ed. (See related article on Nurturing
the Nurturers.)
The Art and Soul of Healing has been described as a
weekend workshop for medical and mental health care
providers to unlock personal wisdom, remove blocks,
renew goals
maintaining the integrity of your
profession in this time of change. Participants
will discover that in loving themselves deeply, they
can discover the truths of being in relationship.
Based on the format of Circling the Soul: Coming Home
to Yourself workshops, this extended version is
specially designed to give healthcare providers the
skills needed to apply the concepts in their own practises.
These are the skills Ken Hamilton started using in both
his life and practise twenty-three years ago.
After a full day on Saturday, participants will be
able to relax and enjoy an evening of entertainment
by Maine singer/songwriter Leah Wolfsong and Her Very
Fine Band. T-Shirts will be available on which participants
can draw mandalas of becoming. The outdoor
facilities on Hebron Academys picturesque campus,
including cross country ski trails for hiking, tennis
courts, a track, and ball fields, will be available
for participants, as well as the indoor pool with open
hours both Saturday and Sunday.
For more information or to register, call Laurie at
207-743-9373. If you have a favorite healthcare practitioner
who might like to have a brochure on the workshop, let
Laurie know.
Nurturing the Nurturers top
by Jane Hindle Bamberg
The Nurturers group was conceived in the spring of 1996
with Ken Hamilton as its primary and initial mover.
Its formation and development have been driven by the
knowledge and perception that the health care field
is seriously lacking in nurturance.
Several professionals involved in healthcare and other
aspects of individualized service to the public convened
every two to three months, spending weekends together.
Initially the groups purpose was two-fold. Based
on the premise that service professionals can offer
better quality services in proportion to how well they
take care of themselves, the group devoted significant
time to nurturing themselves.
Our second purposeevaluating the areas and extent
of unmet nurturance needs in the health-care field and
determining where we might be able to remediate those
unmet needshas continued for the group and become
our primary focus.
Despite changes in the group make up, the core group
has remained stable for over a year. Three original
members, Ken Hamilton, Bruce St. Thomas, and Susan Thompson,
have been joined by Jim Mitchell, Jane Hindle Bamberg,
and Barbara Sinclair.
During the past year, the Nurturers' core group has
concentrated on developing and presenting one- and two-
day workshops The Art and Soul of Healing and Circling
the Soul: Coming Home to Yourself. In these workshops,
reviewing ones life experiences through art, writing,
and small-group sharing enables one to clarify intention
and promote growth. This can be valuable to anyone,
but is particularly valuable for health-care providers.
For these providers, the quality and degree of nurturance
is potentially much greater for clients, through enhanced
relationship-centered care.
Through offering more and more workshops and professional
presentations in a wider and wider geographical area,
the Nurturers plan to expand this awareness and potential
for greater nurturance in healthcare.
The Big Ride top
by Susan Scully
The journey began long ago before the knowing, but the
knowing started before the trek, and the trek started
last August. The minute I saw the full page ad asking
for volunteers to ride The Big Ride Across America by
bike this summer for the American Lung Association,
I knew I had to go. It grew into an unexplainable Light
which I couldnt ignore, urging me upward to places
Ive only dreamed of going, and inward to places
Ive never been.
Its almost a fever which has riveted me to
what is, and what can be, and has driven me to do
things which I least want to do
- like training for hours every day before sunrise,
- like asking people for help,
- like giving up hot fudge sundaes
but whenever I ask, why?, my
soul answers, and I hear my name.
Journey
by Susan Scully
I heard a mantra of Light
which does not speak, except in
the safe silences of my knowing
where it has spoken me
changed my name;
become my breath, become
your breath becoming mine
being my souls Utterance;
being my whole lifes cadence and
the cadence of the earth, breathing
me over her fierce mountains,
across her wild and wrinkled plains,
Home.
Susan Scully is a HOPEr from Portland,
Maine
HOPE Ripples: and
Membership in the Circle of Friends of HOPE
Edited by Ken Hamilton, MD, the founder; © 1998.
Ripples is distributed quarterly without cost to members
of The Circle of Friends of HOPE and to HOPE
group participants. To all others, the cost of an annual
subscription is $5.00.
HOPE members and group participants are invited
to submit personal stories and information about individual
or group activities and experiences. HOPE is a human
interest organization that believes in the value of
the anecdote. Wed like you to consider submitting
yours!
Memberships in the Circle of Friends of HOPE come
with your voluntary, tax-deductible contributions, less
the cost of Ripples, are used to support HOPEs
development and implementation of outreach programs
such as the highly successful Hope for Schools. Membership
in the Circle of Friends of HOPE gives access to
the tapes, books and T-shirts that we sell bringing
our simple yet challenging message. Please make out
your check to HOPE Your support makes our mission
a success. Thank you.
HOPEs annual fund drive is under way. Through
a direct mail appeal and now this request in Ripples,
we are asking our supporters to consider a donation
to help with the operating costs of HOPE Your generosity
makes it possible for us to continue providing services.
Please consider one of the the following levels of giving:
Friend: $50-$99
Donor $100-$499
Patron $500-$999
Benefactor: $1000 and above
Please send your tax-deductible donation to: HOPE.
PO Box 276, South Paris, ME 04281
We would love to have your HOPE story for Ripples!
Please send it to the HOPE office, PO Box 276, South
Paris, ME 04281 or email it to
hope-at-hopehealing.org.
If you don't think you are a writer, record it onto
a tape and send that to the office. The editor will
transcribe and edit it for you!
top
|